Site Search


Other Resources
News Archive






Robert Saxton Interview

Posted on 11 February 2005. © Copyright 2004-2021 Composition:Today


Robert Saxton is a leading figure in British Contemporary music. He is currently University Lecturer and Tutorial Fellow at Worcester College, Oxford. Future works include a work for Steven Isserlis and The Wandering Jew - a dramatic radio operatic fantasy commissioned by BBC Radio 3

Tell us something about your background.

My mother's family, who came to England in the early years of the 20th century as refugees, were Jews from Krakow (Poland) but were, in fact, citizens of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. My father's family were Jewish refugees from Lithuania and Russia; my paternal grandmother (the musical talent in the family) was a Yorkshire Protestant who converted to Judaism to marry my grandfather. My maternal grandfather, Louis Infield, was a mathematician who, after arriving in England from Poland at the age of 14, went on to take a 'double-First' in maths at Queen's College, Cambridge and subsequently worked for the civil service, receiving the OBE for being involved in organising food rationing in WW1; he also wrote a children's play and translated Kant's Ethics from German into English (published). His cousin, Leopold Infeld, was a physicist who worked as Einstein's assistant at Princeton. He was a Communist and, eventually, returned to 'cold war' Poland, where he worked as an Eastern Bloc scientist. My mother is a doctor (retired) and my father, having fought in WW2 (North Africa and Italy) as a tank captain, remained in the army as part of British Army Intelligence during the Greek Civil War. He eventually became a barrister, retiring as a law reporter on The Times. My sister, Vivienne, is principal of a college of dance and my partner, Teresa Cahill, is a singer and professor of voice at Trinity College of Music.

How did you start composing?

I was in recorder class at school, aged 6, and I preferred writing music down to practising!

What was your first success as a composer?

Success is a 'dangerous' word, particularly in our media-saturated world. Without engaging in false modesty, I can say that, in terms of artistic 'success', I feel genuinely that I have only, in the last two or three years, begun to get anywhere near writing the music (both technically and in terms of the structure/expression ratio) I envisaged as a boy. In terms of 'literal' success, then gaining a publisher as a student (as a result of an SPNM workshop) and winning 1st prize at Gaudeamus in Holland from the international jury. as the youngest composer represented (I was 21). This was followed by my post-graduate degree submission at Oxford being selected by the ISCM for performance at the Beethovenhalle in Bonn in 1977. It all helped me to 'get going'.

Where do your ideas come from?

I don't know. One has to define the/an Idea, and Schoenberg came nearer than most. Any professional artist (in whatever medium) has ideas in the head continuously. The primary effort (and pleasure!) is to 'knock these into shape', so that much of one's waking hours are spent, not in producing 'a product', but in working AT ideas in many ways. There is a difference (made clear by the great German mathematician Frege) between an Idea and a Conception, but this is not the place to go further along this route!

Do you have particular techniques - one's you come back to again and again? Tell us a bit about them.

Yes. There is clearly a difference between Technique, which I see as Method (as opposed to System), and specific Techniques, such as I teach at university when tutoring 16th century polyphony or Fugue. I was trained not only thoroughly as regards Harmony and Counterpoint, but also as a serial composer, and I have methods which I apply in general. However, what seems to me to matter, and it is something which I encourage composition students to concentrate on, is sketching/drafting. If one has methods which can be applied from work to work all to the good, but in order for this not to become mechanical, then it is vital to sketch from 'various angles' ( I use the visual imagery purposely, because painters are expert at sketching). By so doing, there is less chance of method becoming (mere) routine. One of the misconceptions which we are continually offered about our 'post-serial' environment is that this implies the end of serialism. Of course we are no longer 'obeying rules' in a naive sense, but that is all surface; what serial training offers a (young) composer is a technical grounding in profound awareness of all compositional parameters, and this refreshes one's hearing, and appreciation, of tonality and its structural consequences. This is 'real' Technique and is ignored, I believe, to the detriment of virtually every aspect of current composition. A painter who paints figuratively, but who has practised (not merely read about) cubism, abstraction and other specific Techniques, will 'come out the other side' as it were. This seems to me to be professional responsibility, a condition I prefer to cultural ( and technical) amnesia!

What's the worst thing about composing?

Feeling, as my teacher Elisabeth Lutyens used to say, that one's inner ear has 'gone dead'. This is familiar to most composers, and may last weeks or a day. It seems to be part of the so-called 'creative cycle' and is, medically-analytically, related to a 'lowered state' (involving aspects of depression). It happens to me when I am about to begin to 'fix' a piece on paper, and may be connected with 'the moment of Truth'. However one analyses it, it can be debilitating. The cure, for me, is to turn my attention to my teaching and administrative duties, until the 'mood' passes. Perhaps unusually, I am infinitely happier at my desk than attending performances of my music. I sit in the audience wishing I was listening to Haydn or Mozart--- certainly anything other than my own work. The danger in admitting this, of course, is that an audience can respond by saying that they don't want to either!

And the best?

When sketching, 'playing' with technical/structural ideas, relating detail to whole and sensing cohesion. (This is not the same as an analytical search for organic unity in Brahms(!)---- that is a different 'animal' altogether). The music is 'roaring away' in the background of one's thought processes, and has to be captured with a compositional 'butterfly net'. It is utterly absorbing and is a long way from the 'surface' machinery of the '(un)-musical world'. Absorption in one's work, and the intensity required, does not necessarily mean that a composer isn't 'communicating' (to use that ridiculous current term). In deed, the opposite is the case----- only through such concentration is the 'real' relationship between expression and structure, which I spoke of earlier, come to the fore.

What are you working on at the moment

A brief anthem 'Locus iste' for the choir of St Catharine's College, Cambridge and (on-going) a dramatic myth The Wandering Jew for BBC Radio 3, which ahs been 'in progress' for several years. I am thinking about an anthem commissioned by the Friends of Christ Church Cathedral, Oxford for Stephen Darlington and the choir of the cathedral and a work for the Arditti String Quartet (provisionally for 2007). I am also planning a book about composition which publisher is currently interested in.

What inspires you to write?

Working; I have never met a creative artist (or scientist) who didn't 'admit' that the process of working is, in itself, inspiring. There are, naturally, aspects of my 'cultural heritage' and education (in the broadest sense) which contribute to ideas in general, but these are not for me to define.

What advice would you give to a young composer just starting out?

First, let me quote Schoenberg, from an interview (in English) which he gave to Halsey Stevens not long before he died: ' you must learn from the masters [Bach, Mozart, Beethoven and Brahms]... but you must not imitate. You must take the essence and create something new'. There it is in a nutshell. Your 'Masters' may be different ones granted, but Schoenberg is right here. Forgetting university courses which ponder whether or not history is dead and whether or not post-Hegelian and Marxist ideas about progress are finished, any composer, painter or writer who is truly absorbed in what they are doing (ie: not opportunistically 'using' the arts as a vehicle for 'success' or a 'career') will not only respect their predecessors--- far more, they will love them. The sheer joy that can be gained from studying music from many centuries (I purposely avoid the current over-played 'multi-cultural' politicised jargon and its inferences, which is merely a gloss) and 'feeling 'its progress/transformation is essential. Remember, one must sense the music, not merely learn about it; Bach copied out music by his predecessors, and there's no substitute for learning about correct voice-leading, from Byrd to Webern. I would encourage student composers to do this by hand--- the computer is wonderful, but the 'fabric' of music has to be physically experienced. A painter or sculptor cannot truly learn their craft by means of computer graphics only. Having said this, one must, as Schoenberg says, go on. This is not a 'Modernist manifesto'----- not at all. It is simply facing reality; if you really are a composer, then you will see strategies, imagine new solutions to problems which emerge from a combination of your studies and your imaginative world. This is more sophisticated (and 'true') than any misconceptions about 'originality' or 'creativity', unfortunately prevalent in our education system at present. As for the 'musical world'------ I can only advise from a subjective point-of-view. There's no doubt that, where as 25 years ago or so, any serious listener respected Bartok, Varese and Schoenberg (for example), and would be prepared to listen to, and consider, Boulez's latest pieces with intelligent ( and objective) consideration, we now have a 'fast' environment, where 'instant communication' (which, literally, means nothing where serious art is concerned---- it is non-sense) and a 'down-grading' of the role/position of complex/challenging work have led to a lowering of expectation(s). The voice-leading in much American minimalist music is poor by traditional standards (I won't name names here) and there are naive and untenable concepts of 'tonality' and a host of associated problems. In the light of this, a young composer has to think deeply about what he/she wishes to achieve, and whether or not it is worth the effort and, indeed, sacrifice. Many today opt for the commercial sector--- my advice here is, if doing so, don't treat it as an 'easy' option. If going down this route, do it properly and become a craftsman. All commercial composers that I know constantly complain at the lack of technical expertise displayed across the board by many of those wanting to go into this area of the profession. the answer to all this is simple: take Schoenberg's advice seriously. At all levels, know what you are doing and be an expert, just as a doctor has to.

Do you have a routine? A place that's special

I try to work in my study when not teaching. On days when I am on 'full academic duty' (4 days per week in term) this is not possible, of course. On my so-called research day, I am invariably busy with meetings and other academic institutional matters. I keep notebooks and work anywhere, at any time. I have always done so. This is why it is important for all composers to learn to work 'in their heads', and not to be tied to the keyboard.

How does your work as a teacher influence your composing?

It doesn't, with regard to ideas at any level, but it does in terms of having to objectify my thoughts and act as a 'musical therapist' much of the time! Teaching Harmony and Counterpoint (as opposed to 'free' composition, although I don't like the idea that there is a 'gap') and lecturing on various topics, I am constantly pondering (with students) many aspects of structure and 'meaning', whether it is in the context of a late Haydn quartet or Steve Reich. Certainly tutoring undergraduates in 'formal' techniques has a profound effect, because one is continuously aware of how very good Purcell, Bach et al were at what they did, in terms of realising ideas coherently! So, we all learn from this. In talking to composition students, one naturally speaks of many things and they (hopefully) prevent me from 'getting rusty' and keep me on my intellectual and musical toes--- then, when I shut my study door, I 'switch off' at a conscious level and return to my own (inner) compositional world.


Interview by Composition:Today © Copyright 2004-2021

Comments by other Members


Posted by :  Dr J at 17:12 on 13 May 2006
Robert Saxton is wonderful!

Posted by :  jamseales0 at 08:30 on 14 July 2021
Your article has piqued a lot of positive interest. I can see why since you have done such a good job of making it interesting. [url=https://moderndogmagazine.com/what-can-i-give-my-dog-for-pain]http://moderndogmagazine.com/what-can-i-give-my-dog-for-pain[/url]
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:02 on 17 July 2021
I just astounded aided by the test most people made to choose this specified share wonderful. Marvelous recreation! face mask
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 13:15 on 25 July 2021
Wrapze brings home reusable essentials. Our mission is to produce high quality and eco-friendly products to save the planet from waste Indoor mouse traps
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 13:55 on 29 July 2021
Freezing consideration perhaps it is an understanding to create could possibly help everybody else is having troubles searching though My group is some unclear a lot more i am permitted to get details and even communications information at these. walmartone associate login
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 14:29 on 21 August 2021
Thank you for another great article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such information. volume rebonding singapore
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 08:27 on 22 August 2021
This is a great post. I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again. home remodeling near me
Posted by :  jamsebond0 at 16:18 on 22 August 2021
Beckside Machinery offering Compact Tractor Power Harrows, View our Power Harrows Beckside Machinery, the UK s premier compact tractor attchment company, Please visit our website for more informations, Thank You. power harrow
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 14:14 on 23 August 2021
I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. basin taps
Posted by :  jamsebond0 at 20:56 on 01 September 2021
If you are looking for Best facial in Bedok, Perfect Beauty- Bedok is dedicated to the highest quality of beauty treatments delivered with understanding, empathy and care. We are located conveniently at the heart of Bedok Central behind Bedok Mall. Please visit our website to contact us, Thank You. Best facial in Bedok
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 05:04 on 09 September 2021
Have you been looking for a professional and cheap legit Liquid Incense ​online shop who does worldwide shipping? Or herbal Incense for sale? Please visit this anchor text to a legit supplier of Herbal incense in USA where you can buy real synthetic incense online.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 07:40 on 10 September 2021
Hindiyojana.in is a dedicated portal to share detailed information regarding various government schemes. We cover central govt's and state wise schemes. Be advised that this is not official website of any scheme and is not linked with any Indian govt's ministry. Indian Government Schemes
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:20 on 10 September 2021
Bee Queen Fillers has already proven to be a reliable supplier of aesthetic products and medical tools worldwide. We are proud of our competitive price, supply capabilities, and professional service. Click this url: https://beequeenfillers.com ​to visit our website, Bee Queen Fillers is one solution to the multiple worries about supplies of aesthetic products and instruments. Please visit our website to get 10% Discount on 100% orignal Products. Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 13:49 on 16 September 2021
Best crystals for love, Romance, Marriage | Effectively Heal Heart Chakra, Learn shop the best crystals to manifest love, happiness Healing your Heart Chakra will change your life Love rituals Learn how to do them correctly.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 19:10 on 16 September 2021
Innerfyre Co | Candles, Hush candles, Essential Oils, and Scents - Essential Oil Candles That Inspire Joy, Visit our website & View our best-selling scented candle company, essential oil roll-ons, and room sprays and pillow mists.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 17:26 on 17 September 2021
Best Baby Jogging Stroller Reviews, Top Picks and Buying Guides, At Baby Jogging Stroller, You ll Get the Jogging Stroller Infomation as Best, Top Picks, Buying Guide, Stroller Reviews and Buying Guide, Please visit our website for more information, Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 07:14 on 20 September 2021
Howley Carpet Providing carpet cleaner cork ​with professional and reliable Prices cleaning services to domestic and commercial customers in Fermoy, Co Cork, Please visit our website for more details, Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 08:03 on 20 September 2021
Beauty Studio is your next go-to place for Best Eyelash Extensions in LA, Permanent MakeUp Lips, Premium Anti-Aging Facial, and other beauty treatments. Russian Eyelash Volume Fill
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 19:34 on 20 September 2021
Best new 2022 weight loss ideas for women, Please visit this informative articleand click to the anchor text readers digest diet pills, You will also discover the weight loss pill that has 2 special formulas one that burns your fat away in the day and the other that burns your fat as you sleep. 5 Remarkable Weight Loss Pills For Women You Have Probably Never Heard Of.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:38 on 22 September 2021
Best ERISA attorney las vegas ​- Law Office of Julie Mersch, Call Julie Mersch Law at 702 387 5868 nevada long term disability lawyer near you Expert Attorney Over 20 years of experience She offers premium legal services, Visit our website and find out how we can fight for you. Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 16:55 on 22 September 2021
Are yoou looking for visitor visa to Canada , Dreamland Immigration is skilled professional ICCRC certified Canadian immigration consultants with years of experience and numerous successful immigration cases, We manage our client’s case from start point up to the final stage. Please visit our website for more information, Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 10:55 on 30 September 2021
Elevate your productivity with our software iso 9001. Free Trial QUALITYWEB 360 for 14 days and convince yourself we are the best option to get the ISO 9001 Certification.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 19:24 on 07 October 2021
Get the best advice from a real estate attorney chicago, The Chicagoland lawyer by Abdilla and Associates. What Can a Chicago Real Estate Attorney Do For You? Visit his site for more info & Set Up a Free Consultation Today! real estate attorney chicago
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 13:20 on 12 October 2021
Get True Reviews for the Online Products in India-Best Review website, Revexpo ​is one of the True best reviews website in India provides genuine reviews from online buyers their experience
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 17:38 on 14 October 2021
Want To Buy Diamond Rings? Visit our website DIAMOND PRICE|GIA 、IGI 、AGSSEARCH ,For more information click to the anchor text diamond
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 06:49 on 16 October 2021
Incoming takeaway service 外賣推介 Recommendation & Promotion|Exclusive free shipping offer|Get Your food at meeting 到會美食 ​or 2-100 people set meal|Pre-ordered party food delivered on the same day|Kamadelivery.com, They also accept large-scale catering services for large and small birthday parties, banquets, company events, friend gatherings or children's birthday parties, Kama is one of the leading catering service in Hong Kong.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 09:11 on 17 October 2021
we have been selling wigs and hairpieces for men and women in our wigs Canada ​store. Shop wig, hair accessories, hats and turbans, hair care tools, makeup and beauty
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:58 on 17 October 2021
Get Your Mobile Phone Repaired by Certified Professionals, Authorized mobile service center Axiom Care, mobile repair service center for nokia repair, samsung repair, huawei repair, iphone repair & mobile screen repair center proefessionaly for all other major brands. Our 20+ years of experience by authorization from all the major Brands will guide you through.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 17:48 on 17 October 2021
Experienced las vegas ERISA lawyer , At the Law Office of Julie A. Mersch, short term disability ERISA nevada, we have the skill and experience to assert your employee benefits rights effectively under ERISA lawyer las vegas. Our founding attorney, Julie A. Mersch, has more than a quarter-century of experience in insurance and employment law. This includes many years of successfully handling ERISA cases for clients in the Las Vegas area and throughout Nevada.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 18:37 on 17 October 2021
Soulager les maux de dos et les douleurs cervicales,Des produits innovants pour soulager vos douleurs lombaires et cervicales naturellement et rapidement, évacuer votre stress et vous relaxer Livraison offerte. https://cervi-care.com Soulagez vos maux de dos, vos douleurs cervicales et votre stress ​en douceur avec nos solutions alternatives.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 08:40 on 18 October 2021
Buy Oxycodone 30mg Oxycodone 30mg is a pain reliever from the opioid family that is used for moderate to severe pain It s manufacturer by Epic Pharma, Buy oxycodone ​30mg online - Sealed Bottle.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 11:07 on 18 October 2021
I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much. this
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:50 on 18 October 2021
I admire what you have done here. I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the comments that this is working for you as well. this
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 06:26 on 21 October 2021
Jennifer Jones Fathom Realty | 937-516-7552 | Real Estate Agent, Central Ohio Realty offers information for New Construction Home, Buying, and Selling Search for New Home Build, Prelisting & properties in the Columbus, Ohio area, Please viasit website for more information, Thank You. New Home Build
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 07:09 on 22 October 2021
WinSlot : Casino Online Terpercaya di Indonesia , WinSlot merupakan situs judi online dengan winrate tinggi yang menyediakan permainan judi slot online uang asli paling populer di Indonesia.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 19:53 on 22 October 2021
customizable kids glasses - Our sun lenses have UV protection, and we’ve included our most popular designs below for a no-hassle check-out. If you want customization or to see how the style fits, then you can design your own pair and also see how it looks here.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 20:54 on 22 October 2021
Skhokho Company Software Cloud Based Business Management Software, CRM, HRM, SaaS, Business Management Software for Small Business, or Medium Sized Enterprises, Packaged with everything your company needs to manage HR files, employee leave, team tasks, customer information, client invoices, projects milestones and tasks and sales CRM. Please visit our website ​& Start with a 14-day FREE trial - no credit card needed. Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:56 on 24 October 2021
Great Information sharing .. I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info.Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post. [url=https://articledirectoryproject.com/what-makes-online-casinos-the-best-for-gaming-enthusiasts/]directory[/url]
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 11:36 on 25 October 2021
A brand you can trust. Gurl Cases creates cases that aren’t just cute iPhone cases[/url, but also durable so your phone is protected from everything life throws at it. Protect your phone in style with a Gurl Case!Protect your phone in style with a Gurl Case, click here & be the first to hear about our exclusive offers and latest arrivals
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 08:59 on 26 October 2021
DiscordHome is a discord listing website, find discord servers ​and communities here! You can advertise, hire, post resumes and find partners for your discord server. Nsfw discord - Visit our site for more information, Thank You.
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 08:21 on 27 October 2021
Dr James glutathione injection ​1500mg Skin Whitening Injection is not only the highest quality of Reduced Glutathione but also has the highest strength of the skin whitening formula available on the marke
Posted by :  jamseales0 at 12:18 on 28 October 2021
The newest pipes in Moscow may also be designed to create the area much more eco friendly. A huge part of the city's water provide arises from underground pipes which can be shielded with a covering of fine sand and silt. Each day, these pipes are reshaped and refined to ensure they look easy and sparkling, as well as being more secure. As a result, when these pipes are changed, there is significantly less possibility that they may be seeping and flooding. Moreover, when new pipes are set, they are generally softer and created from a higher class of copper in comparison to the pipes which were set in the past many years. труба сварная цена
To post comments you need to become a member. If you are already a member, please log in .